I wonder what the Pilgrim community would have thought of our family had we traveled back in time to share their Thanksgiving meal.
A passage from the journal of William Bradford of Plymouth, Colony, November 26, 1621:
“We were joined in our Thanksgiving feast by a curiously dressed family of four.
“Their young girl refused all sustenance save only a dry piece of bread. We wondered what crime she must have committed to be put on a diet of bread and water. Fearing that she die of a lack of nourishment we demanded the child be given meat, squash and sweet corn. She violently refused. We tried to force the food into her mouth. The child bit and screamed. Mary Jones was able to squeeze a kernel of corn past her lips. The moment it touched her tongue, the child commenced vomiting and writhing in agony. Deacon Jones surmised that she must be possessed by a demon and commanded she be placed in the stocks. Having done so, the child reported that she much preferred confinement in the town square to participating in the feast.
“The boy was a bit more adventurous in his acceptance of our bounty. He consumed a piece of wild turkey sized one by one inches. The only accompaniment he allowed was a slice of potato from which he only took a nibble. He was most surly and refused to participate in conversation. When asked to what he was grateful, he replied that he only found value in throwing a ball through an iron hoop. Deacon Jones pressed him wondering how he could not appreciate beauty of the earth or show gratitude for the grace of our Lord in heaven. The boy answered uttering only two words: ‘whatever dude’. We had never observed such insolence in a child. Thinking that he too must be possessed by a demon, he was also placed in the stocks.
“The parents responded most curiously to the confinement of their children. Rather than weep and beg the constable for mercy they offered no complaint. In fact, they seemed to enjoy the communal feast with a far greater degree of satisfaction without the companionship their children.”